IN.gov - Skip Navigation

Note: This message is displayed if (1) your browser is not standards-compliant or (2) you have you disabled CSS. Read our Policies for more information.

Office of Environment Adjudication

OEA > Decisions > 2007 Decisions 2007 Decisions

2007 OEA 1

Petition for Review of NPDES, Permit No. IN0025607
City of Terre Haute, Wastewater Treatment Plant, Vigo County.
(05-W-J-3551)
January 10, 2007OFFICIAL SHORT CITATION NAME: Terre Haute Wastewater Treatment Plant, 2007 OEA 1.

2007 OEA 8

 

OBJECTIONS TO THE ISSUANCE OF SECOND ORDER MODIFYING ORDER FORMING CLAY TOWNSHIP REGIONAL WASTE DISTRICT, CLAY TOWNSHIP, HAMILTON COUNTY, INDIANA
Clay Township of Hamilton County, Indiana, by Judith F. Hagan, Clay Township Trustee, Petitioner;
The Board of Trustees of the Clay Township Regional Waste District, Respondent;
Board of Commissioners of Boone County and Town of Zionsville, Interveners;
Indiana Department of Environmental Management, Respondent.
(06-W-J-3660)
January 18, 2007OFFICIAL SHORT CITATION NAME: Clay Township Regional Waste District II, 2007 OEA 8.

 

2007 OEA 16

Commissioner, Indiana Department of Environmental Management, Complainant
v.
Ronnie Scherb d/b/a Scherb Dairy, Respondent
(05-S-E-3561)
January 24, 2007OFFICIAL SHORT CITATION NAME: IDEM v. Scherb Dairy II, 2007 OEA 16.

2007 OEA 23

OBJECTION TO THE ISSUANCE OF CONFINED ANIMAL FEEDING OPERATION NOI PERMIT APPROVAL,
HORSESHOE BEND FARMS, MAXWELL FOODS OF INDIANA, INC.
Rachel Carpenter, Wendy Carpenter, Clarence Reedy: Petitioners;
Maxwell Foods of Indiana, Inc.: Permittee/Respondent;
Indiana Department of Environmental Management: Respondent.
(06-W-J-3723)
March 16, 2007OFFICIAL SHORT CITATION NAME: Horseshoe Bend Farms, 2007 OEA 23.

2007 OEA 29

 

OBJECTION TO THE ISSUANCE OF CONFINED ANIMAL FEEDING OPERATION NOI PERMIT APPROVAL,
LOG #6412, MARTINDALE, MAXWELL FOODS OF INDIANA, INC.,
RANDOLPH COUNTY, INDIANA
Rachel Carpenter, Wendy Carpenter, Clarence Reedy: Petitioners;
Maxwell Foods of Indiana, Inc.: Permittee/Respondent;
Indiana Department of Environmental Management: Respondent.
(06-W-J-3726)
March 16, 2007OFFICIAL SHORT CITATION NAME: Maxwell Foods of Indiana, Inc., 2007 OEA 29.

 

2007 OEA 35

 

OBJECTION TO THE ISSUANCE OF CONFINED ANIMAL FEEDING OPERATION NOI PERMIT APPROVAL,
LOG #6443, BUENA VISTA FARMS, MAXWELL FOODS OF INDIANA, INC., RANDOLPH COUNTY, INDIANA
Melvin B. Barnell, Corvin L. Coates, Robbie D. Davis, Dennis Parrish, Dustin Parrish, Barbara Pegg, Richard Pegg, and Curtis Ramer: Petitioners;
Maxwell Foods of Indiana, Inc.: Permittee/Respondent;
Indiana Department of Environmental Management: Respondent.
(06-W-J-3769)
March 16, 2007OFFICIAL SHORT CITATION NAME: Buena Vista Farms, 2007 OEA 35.

 

2007 OEA 41

 

OBJECTION TO THE ISSUANCE OF CONFINED ANIMAL FEEDING OPERATION NOI PERMIT APPROVAL, LOG #6438, INDIAN TRAIL NURSERY, MAXWELL FOODS OF INDIANA, INC., RANDOLPH COUNTY, INDIANA.
Rachel Carpenter, Wendy Carpenter, Courtney Hess, John Zakelj: Petitioners;
Maxwell Foods of Indiana, Inc.: Permittee/Respondent;
Indiana Department of Environmental Management: Respondent.
(06-W-J-3772)
March 16, 2007OFFICIAL SHORT CITATION NAME: Indian Trail Nursery, 2007 OEA 41.

 

2007 OEA 47

Objection to the Denial of Excess Liability Trust Fund Claim No. 9808501-5/FID No. 5324,
Custom Contractors of Evansville, Haubstadt, Gibson County, Indiana
(06-F-J-3737)
April 3, 2007OFFICIAL SHORT CITATION NAME: Custom Contractors of Evansville, 2007 OEA 47.

2007 OEA 53

 

Objections to Issuance of 327 Article 3 Construction Permit Application Plans and Specifications
for Wastewater Treatment Plant and Sanitary Sewer System,
Permit Approval No. 17872, Permit Approval No. 17872R,
Twin Lakes Regional Sewer District,
Monticello, Carroll and White Counties, Indiana.
(06-S-J-3702) Permit Approval No. 17872
(06-S-J-3762) Permit Approval No. 17872R
April 11, 2007OFFICIAL SHORT CITATION NAME: Twin Lakes Regional Sewer District, 2007 OEA 53.

 

2007 OEA 64

Objection to Issuance of Sanitary Sewer Construction Permit No. 18375R,
Proposed Foxmoor Unit 2 and Phase 1 Subdivision, Merrillville, Lake County, Indiana.
(07-W-J-3852)
April 17, 2007OFFICIAL SHORT CITATION NAME: Foxmoor Unit 2, 2007 OEA 64.

2007 OEA 70

Commissioner, Indiana Department of Environmental Management, Complainant
v.
Marie E. Heinold, 2002-12004-S, Respondent
(06-S-E-3709)
May 18, 2007OFFICIAL SHORT CITATION NAME: IDEM v. Heinold, 2007 OEA 70.

2007 OEA 77

Objection to the Issuance of NPDES Permit No. IN00062367, Rattlesnake Creek WWTP Plant and Sanitary Sewer System, White County, Indiana Don Long, Sherry Long, Richard Roach, Rick Roach, Terry Dill: Petitioners; Twin Lakes Regional Sewer District: Permittee/Respondent; Indiana Department of Environmental Management: Respondent. (06-W-J-3817) June 7, 2007OFFICIAL SHORT CITATION NAME: Rattlesnake Creek WWTP, 2007 OEA 77.

2007 OEA 82

Objection to the Denial of Water Quality Certification No. 2005-576-76-RDC-A,
Crooked Lake, Steuben County, Indiana.
Michele Anderson: Petitioner;
Indiana Department of Environmental Management: Respondent.
(06-W-J-3714)
June 15, 2007OFFICIAL SHORT CITATION NAME: Crooked Lake, 2007 OEA 82.

2007 OEA 94

 

Objection to the Denial of Excess Liability Trust Fund Claim of Rowe Brothers, Inc.

ELTF NO. # 200309508 / FAC ID NO. 5341, Indianapolis, Marion County, Indiana.
Rowe Brothers, Inc.: Petitioner;
Indiana Department of Environmental Management: Respondent.
(05-F-J-3650)
June 27, 2007OFFICIAL SHORT CITATION NAME: Rowe Brothers, Inc., 2007 OEA 94.
Judicial Review
: IDEM vs. Rowe Brothers, Inc., 49F12-0707-PL-031388 (Marion Super. Ct. 2009) affirmed.

2007 OEA 106

 

Objection to Determination that Farm is Confined Feeding Operation, Submitted by Samuel L. Lantz,

2819 North Henry County Line Road, Cambridge City, Wayne County, Indiana.
Samuel L. Lantz: Petitioner;
Eric and Lisa Stickdorn: Intervenors;
Indiana Department of Environmental Management: Respondents.
(04-S-J-3458)
June 28, 2007OFFICIAL SHORT CITATION NAME: Samuel L. Lantz CFO Objection, 2007 OEA 106.

2007 OEA 114

 

Objection to Issuance of Approval No. AW 5499/FARM ID#6370 NPDES CAFO ID NO. ING 806370,
Concentrated Animal Feeding Operation, Talara Lykins, Jackson Count, Indiana
Jennings Water, Inc. and Charles and Nancy Fox: Petitioners;
Talara Lykins: Respondent/Permittee;
Indiana Department of Environmental Management: Respondent.
(05-S-J-3602)
June 29, 2007OFFICIAL SHORT CITATION NAME: Talara Lykins - CAFO, 2007 OEA 114.
Judicial Review
: Jennings Water vs. OEA, 49A02-0805-CV-396 (Ind. Ct. App. 2009) affirmed.


2007 OEA 128

Commissioner, Indiana Department of Environmental Management, Complainant
v.
Land Coast Insulation, Inc., Respondent.
(05-A-E-3555)
July 24, 2007OFFICIAL SHORT CITATION NAME: IDEM v. Land Coast Insulation, Inc., 2007 OEA 128.

2007 OEA 139

Objection to the Denial of Excess Liability Trust Fund Claim for Bigfoot #101
ELF No. 9201041 / FID No. 99, Seymour, Jackson County, Indiana
(06-F-J-3811)
July 30, 2007OFFICIAL SHORT CITATION NAME: Bigfoot #101 ELTF, 2007 OEA 139.

2007 OEA 146

 

Objection to Issuance of Construction Permit No. 15345R,

Water Pollution Treatment/Control Facility, Plaza Utilities LLC, Hancock County, Indiana.
Matthew J. Donnelly, Donna Rogler, Howard N. Timmerman, Dorothy Timmerman, Elaine Key, Welby Key, John Peterson, B. Schoppel, Carol Schreiber, Todd Barnes: Petitioners;
Plaza Utilities LLC: Permittee/Respondent;
Indiana Department Of Environmental Management: Respondent.
(07-W-J-3925)
June 6, 2007OFFICIAL SHORT CITATION NAME: Plaza Utilities, LLC, 2007 OEA 146.

2007 OEA 149

 

Objection to the Issuance of Confined Animal Feeding Operation, General NPDES Permit,

NPDES CAFO No. ING806496, Eldon Wray, Jay County, Indiana.
Janet (Walker) Confer, David Confer: Petitioners;
Eldon Wray: Permittee/Respondent;
Indiana Department of Environmental Management: Respondent.
(07-W-J-3887)
August 28, 2007OFFICIAL SHORT CITATION NAME: Eldon Wray CAFO Objection, 2007 OEA 149.

2007 OEA 155

 

Objection to the Issuance of Confined Feeding Operation Approval, Swine Pro 1, LLC,

Animal Waste No. AW-5676, Hancock County, Indiana.
Conley and Nellie Seal, et al: Petitioners;
Swine Pro 1 LLC: Permittee/Respondent;
Indiana Department of Environmental Management: Respondent.
(06-W-J-3825)
September 26, 2007OFFICIAL SHORT CITATION NAME: Swine Pro 1, LLC CFO Objection, 2007 OEA 155.

2007 OEA 164

Objection to Issuance of Sanitary Sewer Construction Permit No. 18509, Independence Hill Conservancy District, Merrillville, Lake County, Indiana. Merrillville Conservancy District, Gary Sanitary District: Petitioners; Independence Hill Conservancy District: Respondent/Permittee; Indiana Department of Environmental Management: Respondent. (07-W-J-3894) October 1, 2007OFFICIAL SHORT CITATION NAME: Independence Hill Conservancy District, 2007 OEA 164.
Judical Review
: Independence Hill Conservancy District vs. IDEM, 45D02-0803-MI-00012                                            
(Lake Super. Ct. 2009) affirmed.

Advisory Decisions

2007 OEA-NFO 0417 (07-W-J-3852) In the Matter of: Objection to Issuance of Sanitary Sewer Construction Permit No. 18375R, Proposed Foxmoor Unit 2 and Phase 1 Subdivision, Merrillville, Lake County, Indiana.